For riders who want a versatile flat pedal, the Crankbrothers Stamp Large stands out as the best overall pick in this lineup for its roomy platform and trail-focused design. The Shimano PD-M520 is a distinct choice for riders who prefer clipless control, while the Shimano PD-EH500 suits those who want both a flat side and an SPD side. Choosing mountain bike pedals comes down to balancing foot grip, platform size, pedal-system preference, and the maintenance tradeoffs of the build. Read on for a side-by-side breakdown of all 14 options and guidance on matching a pedal to your bike and riding habits.
Get sports gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The lineup splits into three clear groups: flat platforms, clipless SPD pedals, and the dual-sided Shimano PD-EH500; decide which interface suits your shoes before comparing bearings or pins.
- The Crankbrothers Stamp Large is the strongest all-around flat-pedal pick for riders who value a broad platform, while its large format may feel excessive for smaller feet or tight clearance needs.
- The Shimano PD-M520 and PD-EH500 serve different clipless needs: the M520 prioritizes SPD engagement on both sides, while the EH500 trades that simplicity for a usable flat side.
- Several ROCKBROS, MZYRH, and other aluminum options overlap in purpose. Platform shape, pin layout, and bearing construction are more useful tie-breakers than the shared alloy label.
- Nylon-composite flats offer a different tradeoff from aluminum: they can appeal to riders seeking a simpler, non-metal platform, while alloy pedals are the more natural shortlist for riders prioritizing a rigid metal body.
| ROCKBROS Nylon Fiber Platform Bike Pedals, 9/16-Inch |  | Best for Comfortable, Low-Fuss Riding | Body material: Nylon fiber | Spindle material: Cr-Mo steel | Thread size: 9/16 inches | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| GEWAGE 9/16-Inch Flat Bike Pedals with Removable Anti-Skid Pins |  | Best for Adjustable Grip | Platform material: Aluminum alloy | Spindle material: Chrome-molybdenum steel | Thread size: 9/16 inch | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ROCKBROS Lightweight Aluminum Mountain Bike Pedals |  | Best Lightweight Aluminum Pick | Material: Aluminum alloy, carbon fiber, and stainless steel | Platform dimensions: 98 × 90 mm | Weight: 151 g per pedal | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| FIFTY-FIFTY Mountain Bike Pedals, Non-Slip Nylon Composite Flat Pedals |  | Best for Low-Clearance Trail Riding | Body material: Nylon composite | Spindle material: Cr-Mo | Weight: 351 g per pair | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Hapleby 9/16-Inch Flat Bike Pedals with Sealed Bearings |  | Best for Easy, All-Round Installation | Body material: Aluminum alloy | Spindle material: Chromium-molybdenum | Thread size: 9/16 inches | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Universal 9/16-Inch Non-Slip Platform Bike Pedals |  | Best for Commuting and Everyday Riding | Material: Polypropylene (PP) | Thread size: 9/16 inch | Weight: 255 g per pair | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Crankbrothers Stamp Flat MTB Pedals, Large |  | Best for Riders with Large Shoes | Platform dimensions: 114 x 114 mm | Body material: Nylon composite | Traction pins: One-piece, replaceable | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ROCKBROS Aluminum Mountain Bike Flat Pedals |  | Best for a Wide Aluminum Platform | Material: CNC-machined aluminum alloy | Platform width: 101 mm | Weight: 0.66 lb | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| MZYRH Mountain Bike Pedals, CNC Machined Aluminum, 9/16-Inch, Sealed 3-Bearing |  | Best for Multi-Bike Compatibility | Material: High-strength aluminum alloy | Bearing type: Sealed, three-bearing | Thread size: 9/16 inch | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Shimano PD-M520 SPD Clipless Bicycle Pedals with Cleats, Black |  | Best for SPD Clipless Riding | Brand: Shimano | Model: PD-M520 | Pedal type: Clipless SPD | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Shimano PD-EH500 Dual-Sided SPD and Flat Bike Pedals |  | Best for Mixed Shoe Setups | Brand: Shimano | Model: PD-EH500 | Pedal type: Dual-sided: SPD clip-in and flat | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ROCKBROS Aluminum MTB Pedals Wide Platform Flat Pedals with Sealed Bearings |  | Best Wide-Platform Lightweight Pick | Material: Aluminum alloy | Platform width: 101 mm | Weight: 0.66 lb (302 g) | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| GPMTER 9/16-Inch Aluminum Flat Bike Pedals with 16 Anti-Skid Pins |  | Best for Moderate, Predictable Grip | Brand: GPMTER | Material: Aluminum alloy | Thread size: 9/16 in | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| MZYRH Mountain Bike Pedals, 9/16-Inch CNC-Machined Aluminum Alloy, Sealed 3-Bearing |  | Best for Multi-Bearing Construction | Material: High-strength aluminum alloy | Bearing: 3 sealed bearings | Thread size: 9/16 in | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| mountain bike pedal | Weight | Thread size | Material |
|---|---|---|---|
| ROCKBROS Nylon Fiber Platform | 12.8 ounces | 9/16 inches | — |
| GEWAGE 9/16-Inch Flat Bike Ped | 300 g | 9/16 inch | — |
| ROCKBROS Lightweight Aluminum | 151 g per pedal | — | Aluminum alloy, carbon fiber, and stainless steel |
| FIFTY-FIFTY Mountain Bike Peda | 351 g per pair | 9/16 inch | — |
| Hapleby 9/16-Inch Flat Bike Pe | 14.4 ounces | 9/16 inches | — |
| Universal 9/16-Inch Non-Slip P | 255 g per pair | 9/16 inch | Polypropylene (PP) |
| Crankbrothers Stamp Flat MTB P | — | — | — |
| ROCKBROS Aluminum Mountain Bik | 0.66 lb | 9/16 inch | CNC-machined aluminum alloy |
| MZYRH Mountain Bike Pedals | 0.45 lb each | 9/16 inch | High-strength aluminum alloy |
| Shimano PD-M520 SPD Clipless B | 380 g | 9/16 inch | Aluminum |
| Shimano PD-EH500 Dual-Sided SP | 1.2 lb | — | Aluminum |
| ROCKBROS Aluminum MTB Pedals W | 0.66 lb (302 g) | Listed as 9/16 in and 16-Sep; verify before purchase | Aluminum alloy |
| GPMTER 9/16-Inch Aluminum Flat | 15.2 oz | 9/16 in | Aluminum alloy |
| MZYRH Mountain Bike Pedals | 0.45 lb each | 9/16 in | High-strength aluminum alloy |
More Details on Our Top Picks
ROCKBROS Nylon Fiber Platform Bike Pedals, 9/16-Inch
The wide 4.7 x 4.1-inch platform and lightweight nylon fiber body make these a sensible choice for riders who want steady foot support without a metal pedal’s feel. Compared with the aluminum-bodied GEWAGE flat pedals, the ROCKBROS uses a simpler nylon platform and sealed DU bearings, making it a straightforward fit for mixed use across mountain, hybrid, and commuter bikes. Anti-skid pins help hold shoes in place, while the 12.8-ounce weight keeps the pair light. The tradeoff is that the pins can gather mud on sloppy trails, and the nylon construction may not suit riders who prioritize a metal body for repeated hard impacts. I’d choose these for everyday trail and path riding, not the roughest downhill use.
Pros:- Wide platform supports the foot across longer rides
- Lightweight nylon fiber body
- Anti-skid pins help limit foot movement
- Sealed DU bearings are designed to resist water and dust
Cons:- Pins may collect mud on wet, sticky trails
- Nylon body may be less suited to repeated hard impacts than aluminum options
Best for: Trail and hybrid riders who want a broad, lightweight platform for casual to moderate riding.
Not ideal for: Riders tackling frequent muddy or aggressive downhill trails who need easy-to-clean pins or a metal pedal body.
- Body material:Nylon fiber
- Spindle material:Cr-Mo steel
- Thread size:9/16 inches
- Platform dimensions:4.7 x 4.1 inches
- Weight:12.8 ounces
- Bearing type:Sealed DU bearings
- Color:Black
- Compatibility:BMX, MTB, hybrid, fixed gear, cruiser, track, cyclocross, dirt, and folding bikes
Our verdict“Choose these for a lightweight, wide platform suited to everyday mountain and mixed-surface riding, but look elsewhere for demanding downhill use.”
GEWAGE 9/16-Inch Flat Bike Pedals with Removable Anti-Skid Pins
For riders who want to tune their shoe hold, the 16 replaceable pins per pedal are the defining advantage here. They give the GEWAGE more scope for pin maintenance or replacement than the ROCKBROS nylon fiber pedals, whose pins are a simpler part of a broad everyday-use design. A CNC-machined aluminum platform, three sealed bearings, and a 14 mm profile make this a capable flat-pedal option for trail riding. The 100 × 104 mm platform is compact enough to avoid an oversized feel, though riders seeking more foot coverage may prefer the ROCKBROS’s larger stated platform. Installation uses an 8 mm Allen key, and the included tool plus left/right labels help, but this is not a pedal to fit with only a pedal wrench.
Pros:- Sixteen replaceable pins per pedal allow pin servicing
- Three sealed bearings help shield the internals from water and dust
- Lightweight aluminum alloy platform
- Left and right markings and an included tool aid installation
Cons:- Installation requires an 8 mm Allen key
- Platform is smaller than the stated platform on the ROCKBROS nylon fiber pedals
Best for: Mountain bikers who want adjustable, replaceable grip pins and are comfortable installing pedals with an Allen key.
Not ideal for: Riders who need a larger foot platform or whose crank setup requires installation with a pedal wrench rather than an 8 mm Allen key.
- Platform material:Aluminum alloy
- Spindle material:Chrome-molybdenum steel
- Thread size:9/16 inch
- Platform dimensions:100 × 104 mm
- Profile:14 mm
- Pins:16 per pedal, 8 per side; replaceable
- Bearings:3 sealed bearings
- Weight:300 g
- Installation:8 mm Allen key
Our verdict“Pick the GEWAGE if replaceable grip pins and three sealed bearings matter more to you than a larger platform or wrench-based installation.”
ROCKBROS Lightweight Aluminum Mountain Bike Pedals
At 151 g per pedal, this ROCKBROS model is the lightest clearly specified aluminum option in this group, making it a fit for riders who care about keeping rotating weight down. Its 98 × 90 mm platform is smaller than the GEWAGE’s 100 × 104 mm body, so it favors a compact feel over extra foot coverage. Five stainless steel pins per pedal and textured surfaces provide grip, while the mix of one sealed bearing and one DU bearing keeps the design distinct from the GEWAGE’s three sealed bearings. The main caveat is the supplied note that its solid lubrication melts after several rides, which may call for attention as the pedals settle in. I’d favor this model for weight-conscious trail riders, not buyers seeking the most pin coverage or a larger platform.
Pros:- Low stated weight of 151 g per pedal
- Aluminum platform with stainless steel grip pins
- Textured surface adds another source of shoe traction
- Standard 9/16-inch spindle fits many bike types
Cons:- Smaller platform than the GEWAGE model
- Uses one sealed bearing and one DU bearing rather than three sealed bearings
- Solid lubrication is reported to melt after several rides
Best for: Weight-conscious mountain bikers who prefer a compact aluminum platform and want to keep pedal mass low.
Not ideal for: Riders who want a larger platform, more grip pins, or a bearing setup made entirely from sealed bearings.
- Material:Aluminum alloy, carbon fiber, and stainless steel
- Platform dimensions:98 × 90 mm
- Weight:151 g per pedal
- Spindle size:9/16 inch
- Bearings:One sealed bearing and one DU bearing
- Grip pins:Five stainless steel pins per pedal
- Included components:2 pedals
- Warranty:1 year
- Color:Black
Our verdict“Choose this ROCKBROS model if low pedal weight and a compact aluminum platform outweigh bearing uniformity and a larger contact area.”
FIFTY-FIFTY Mountain Bike Pedals, Non-Slip Nylon Composite Flat Pedals
The FIFTY-FIFTY stands out for its 0.7-inch-thick, 106 × 104 mm platform: a broad contact area with a slim profile that can help reduce pedal strikes on rough trails. Compared with the Hapleby aluminum pedals, it swaps an aluminum body for nylon composite and uses nine replaceable steel pins per side, giving riders more pin coverage and a thinner shape. The Cr-Mo spindle and 351 g pair weight keep the package relatively light, while standard 9/16-inch threads suit many bikes. Its key tradeoff is the body material: nylon composite may be less durable than aluminum under repeated heavy downhill impacts. I’d choose it for technical trails where clearance and grip matter, but prefer a metal-bodied option for hard-charging riding.
Pros:- Thin 0.7-inch profile can help limit pedal strikes
- Wide 106 × 104 mm platform
- Nine replaceable steel pins per side
- Cr-Mo spindle and standard 9/16-inch threads
Cons:- Nylon composite may be less durable than aluminum under heavy downhill impacts
- Pair weight of 351 g is higher than the stated weight of the ROCKBROS lightweight aluminum model
Best for: Trail riders who want a wide, thin pedal with replaceable pins to help maintain grip and reduce pedal strikes.
Not ideal for: Downhill riders who regularly subject pedals to heavy impacts and prefer an aluminum body.
- Body material:Nylon composite
- Spindle material:Cr-Mo
- Weight:351 g per pair
- Platform size:106 × 104 mm
- Thickness:0.7 inch
- Thread size:9/16 inch
- Pins:9 replaceable steel pins per side
- Color:Gum
- Included components:2 pedals, 2 × 1 mm M15 washers, 6 × M3 pins, and 6 × M4 nuts
Our verdict“Pick the FIFTY-FIFTY for a broad, low-profile trail pedal, but choose an aluminum-bodied model if repeated hard impacts are your main concern.”
Hapleby 9/16-Inch Flat Bike Pedals with Sealed Bearings
The Hapleby is a practical pick for riders who want a familiar aluminum body, Cr-Mo spindle, and sealed bearings without a specialized trail-focused shape. Its 3.94 × 3.74-inch platform and six pins per side offer a straightforward blend of foot support and grip. Compared with the FIFTY-FIFTY pedals, the Hapleby is thicker and has fewer pins, so it gives up some low-clearance, high-grip appeal in exchange for an aluminum body and a more general-purpose fit. Two sealed bearings per pedal support everyday use, and the included pedal wrench makes installation more convenient than the GEWAGE, which calls for an 8 mm Allen key. Check crank compatibility first: the standard 9/16-inch thread will not fit every bike.
Pros:- Aluminum alloy body paired with a Cr-Mo spindle
- Two sealed bearings per pedal
- Six anti-skid pins on each side
- Pedal wrench is included
Cons:- Standard 9/16-inch threads may not fit every bike crank
- Platform is smaller and thicker than the FIFTY-FIFTY low-profile design
- Fewer pins per side than the GEWAGE model
Best for: Riders with standard 9/16-inch cranks who want aluminum flat pedals, sealed bearings, and a wrench in the box.
Not ideal for: Riders with a different crank thread size or those seeking a very thin pedal with extensive replaceable pin coverage.
- Body material:Aluminum alloy
- Spindle material:Chromium-molybdenum
- Thread size:9/16 inches
- Bearings:2 sealed bearings per pedal
- Platform dimensions:3.94 × 3.74 inches
- Weight:14.4 ounces
- Pins:6 anti-skid pins per side
- Bike types:Mountain, road, BMX, and folding
- Included components:Pedal wrench
Our verdict“Choose the Hapleby for a conventional aluminum pedal with sealed bearings and included installation hardware, provided your cranks use 9/16-inch threads.”
Universal 9/16-Inch Non-Slip Platform Bike Pedals
I’d put these pedals on a city or hybrid bike before choosing them for demanding trail use. Their dual-sided anti-slip studs give everyday shoes some purchase, while the reflective strips add visibility for rides near traffic in low light. Sealed bearings are designed to resist water and dust, a useful touch for routine outdoor use. Compared with the ROCKBROS Aluminum Mountain Bike Flat Pedals, this pair prioritizes visibility and easy installation over a metal body and trail-oriented construction. The polypropylene platform keeps the pair to 255 g, but riders who want the rigid feel of aluminum may prefer the ROCKBROS or MZYRH aluminum options. Check your crank arms before buying: these use standard 9/16-inch threads, not 1/2-inch threads, and the body material may not suit aggressive riding or frequent impacts.
Pros:- Dual-sided studs add grip for everyday shoes
- Reflective strips improve visibility in low light
- Sealed bearings are designed to resist water and dust
- Marked left and right sides simplify installation
Cons:- Polypropylene may not satisfy riders who want a metal pedal body
- Not compatible with 1/2-inch pedal threads
- City-bike focus makes it less suited to aggressive trail riding
Best for: City and hybrid bike riders who wear ordinary shoes, ride in low light, and want easy-to-identify left and right pedals.
Not ideal for: Trail riders seeking a metal platform for hard impacts, or anyone whose crank arms use 1/2-inch threads.
- Material:Polypropylene (PP)
- Thread size:9/16 inch
- Weight:255 g per pair
- Dimensions:4.05 x 3.74 inches
- Pedal style:Flat platform
- Bike type:City bike
- Bearings:Sealed, designed to resist water and dust
- Warranty:Six months
Our verdict“Choose these for a visibility-minded city or hybrid setup with standard 9/16-inch cranks, not for hard trail use.”
Crankbrothers Stamp Flat MTB Pedals, Large
The Stamp Large is the clearest fit here for riders whose shoes need more room on a flat pedal. Its 114 x 114 mm platform is sized for US 10–15 shoes, giving a broader base than the ROCKBROS Aluminum Mountain Bike Flat Pedals, whose stated 101 mm platform width and under-US-12 recommendation point toward a smaller fit range. The nylon composite body keeps the pedal lightweight, and replaceable pins let riders renew traction rather than replace the whole pedal when pins wear or get damaged. Serviceable IGUS bearings and seals also make ongoing maintenance part of the design. The tradeoff is that riders who prefer an aluminum body may favor ROCKBROS or MZYRH, and the large platform is not the natural pick for smaller shoes or a compact setup.
Pros:- Large 114 x 114 mm platform suits bigger shoes
- Lightweight nylon composite body
- Replaceable traction pins support continued grip
- Serviceable IGUS bearings and seals
Cons:- Large platform may feel oversized for smaller shoes
- Composite body may not suit riders set on aluminum construction
Best for: Trail and all-mountain riders wearing US 10–15 shoes who want a large flat platform and serviceable parts.
Not ideal for: Riders with smaller shoes seeking a compact platform, or those who specifically want an aluminum pedal body.
- Platform dimensions:114 x 114 mm
- Body material:Nylon composite
- Traction pins:One-piece, replaceable
- Bearings:Serviceable IGUS
- Shoe size fit:US 10–15 (EU 43.5–49)
- Pedal type:Flat mountain bike pedal
- Seals:Serviceable
Our verdict“Pick the Stamp Large if your larger shoes need a broad, maintainable platform; choose a smaller aluminum option if compact fit or metal construction matters more.”
ROCKBROS Aluminum Mountain Bike Flat Pedals
These ROCKBROS pedals make sense for riders who want a metal platform with broad foot support without moving to a particularly large pedal. The 101 mm platform, stainless steel pins, and sealed bearings suit mixed mountain, BMX, hybrid, road, and commuter use. Compared with the Crankbrothers Stamp Large, this model has an aluminum body and a smaller stated footprint, while the Stamp gives larger shoes more room and offers serviceable IGUS bearings. The chromoly spindle adds a robust component at the axle, but the listed shoe guidance—under US 12—makes fit less compelling for larger-footed riders than the Stamp. Installation also requires matching the left and right pedals, so check the markings before threading them into the cranks. The aluminum body and pins favor stable footing, though they do not make this the best fit for every shoe size.
Pros:- 101 mm-wide aluminum platform supports the foot
- Stainless steel pins provide traction
- Sealed bearings help keep out water and dust
- Chromoly steel spindle
Cons:- Recommended for shoe sizes under US 12
- Left and right pedals must be matched during installation
- Smaller-footprint fit may not suit riders who need the Stamp Large’s broader platform
Best for: Riders with shoes under US 12 who want an aluminum flat pedal for mountain or mixed-bike use.
Not ideal for: Riders with larger shoes who need more platform area, or anyone unwilling to check left-right orientation during installation.
- Material:CNC-machined aluminum alloy
- Platform width:101 mm
- Weight:0.66 lb
- Spindle material:Chromoly steel
- Bearings:Sealed
- Thread size:9/16 inch
- Compatibility:Most BMX, mountain, hybrid, road, and commuter bikes
- Recommended shoe size:Under US 12
Our verdict“Choose this ROCKBROS pair for a wide aluminum platform and mixed-bike versatility if your shoes fall within its stated size guidance.”
MZYRH Mountain Bike Pedals, CNC Machined Aluminum, 9/16-Inch, Sealed 3-Bearing
The MZYRH aluminum pedals suit riders who want one flat-pedal style across several bikes: the listed compatibility includes mountain, road, BMX, exercise, fixie, and folding bikes. Their sealed three-bearing design is the standout distinction in this group, paired with anti-skid pins and a compact 105 x 91 mm footprint. Compared with the ROCKBROS Aluminum Mountain Bike Flat Pedals, MZYRH specifies three sealed bearings and gives exact pedal dimensions, while ROCKBROS lists a 101 mm platform width and a chromoly spindle. That makes MZYRH appealing to riders focused on bearing layout and cross-bike fit, though the supplied data does not state a shoe-size range or pin replacement details. At 0.45 lb each, the listed weight is per pedal, not per pair; account for that when comparing it with pair-weight figures from other models.
Pros:- High-strength aluminum alloy construction
- Sealed three-bearing design
- Anti-skid pins add shoe grip
- Listed for several bike types, including mountain, BMX, and folding bikes
Cons:- Weight is listed per pedal, which can complicate pair-to-pair comparisons
- No shoe-size guidance is provided
- Pin replacement details are not specified
Best for: Riders who want aluminum flat pedals for several bike styles and value sealed bearings with a specified three-bearing layout.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a stated shoe-size fit, platform width, or replaceable-pin information before choosing.
- Material:High-strength aluminum alloy
- Bearing type:Sealed, three-bearing
- Thread size:9/16 inch
- Weight:0.45 lb each
- Dimensions:4.1 x 3.58 x 1.0 inches each (105 x 91 x 26 mm)
- Grip:Anti-skid pins
- Installation markings:L for left pedal; R for right pedal
- Listed bike compatibility:Mountain, road, BMX, exercise, fixie, and folding bikes
Our verdict“Choose MZYRH if you want aluminum pedals with sealed three-bearing support for multiple bike types and can verify fit for your shoes.”
Shimano PD-M520 SPD Clipless Bicycle Pedals with Cleats, Black
The PD-M520 is the only clipless choice among these five, so it serves a different rider than the flat-platform models rather than competing on shoe support or pin grip. Its SPD-compatible design pairs with the included cleats, giving riders a cleat-based connection instead of the free foot placement offered by the Crankbrothers Stamp Large or aluminum ROCKBROS flats. That connection can suit mountain bikers who already ride SPD shoes and want a consistent clipless setup. The aluminum body and 9/16-inch thread are familiar fit points, but this listing describes the pedal type inconsistently as both clipless and clip-free. I’d verify the intended cleat system before ordering. Riders new to clipless pedals should also expect a different mounting and release routine than with a flat pedal, and this model is a poor match for anyone wanting ordinary shoes to work without cleats.
Pros:- SPD-compatible clipless design
- Cleats included
- Aluminum construction
- Standard 9/16-inch thread
Cons:- Requires compatible SPD shoes and cleats for the intended setup
- Product details conflict by describing the pedals as clipless and clip-free
- Less suitable than flat pedals for riders who want unrestricted foot placement
Best for: Mountain bikers who already use SPD-compatible shoes and want clipless pedals with cleats included.
Not ideal for: Riders who want to use regular shoes or prefer the immediate foot repositioning of flat pedals; buyers should also verify the listing’s conflicting clipless/clip-free wording.
- Brand:Shimano
- Model:PD-M520
- Pedal type:Clipless SPD
- Material:Aluminum
- Thread size:9/16 inch
- Weight:380 g
- Dimensions:6.3 x 4.72 inches
- Included:Cleats
- Color:Black and silver
Our verdict“Choose the PD-M520 if you want an SPD clipless setup and compatible shoes; stick with a flat model if you want to ride in ordinary footwear.”
Shimano PD-EH500 Dual-Sided SPD and Flat Bike Pedals
The PD-EH500 suits riders who want to switch between clip-in cycling shoes and everyday footwear without changing pedals. Its SPD side and grippy flat side make it more adaptable than the all-flat ROCKBROS Aluminum MTB Pedals, while adjustable cleat tension lets riders tune how firmly their shoes release. The included SPD cleats also mean the clip-in setup is ready to use with compatible shoes.
The tradeoff is that the two riding modes are not equally available at once: only one face clips in, so finding the correct side can take a pedal flip when starting. At 1.2 lb, it is also heavier than the ROCKBROS pair listed at 0.66 lb. Its listed thread-size value, 45185, is unclear, so I would verify crank compatibility before buying. This is a flexible choice for mixed commutes and recreational rides, not a dedicated lightweight flat-pedal setup.
Pros:- Two-sided design supports SPD shoes and ordinary footwear
- Adjustable cleat tension allows release feel to be tuned
- SPD cleats are included
- Aluminum construction is designed for durable, low-maintenance use
Cons:- Only one pedal face accepts SPD cleats, so clip-in engagement may take a flip
- Heavier than the ROCKBROS Aluminum MTB Pedals in this roundup
- Listed thread-size value is unclear and should be checked before installation
Best for: Commuters and recreational mountain bikers who alternate between SPD-compatible cycling shoes and sneakers.
Not ideal for: Riders who want a dedicated flat pedal on both sides, prioritize low weight, or cannot verify compatibility with the listed thread size.
- Brand:Shimano
- Model:PD-EH500
- Pedal type:Dual-sided: SPD clip-in and flat
- Material:Aluminum
- Weight:1.2 lb
- Dimensions:7 × 6 in
- Included:SPD cleats
- Warranty:2 years
Our verdict“Choose the PD-EH500 if you need both SPD and flat-pedal options on one bike and can confirm the crank-thread fit.”
ROCKBROS Aluminum MTB Pedals Wide Platform Flat Pedals with Sealed Bearings
The ROCKBROS Aluminum MTB Pedals stand out for riders who want a broad foothold without adding much weight. Their 101 mm platform gives more room to position a shoe than the GPMTER pedals’ listed 3.5 × 3.5-inch dimensions, while the stainless steel anti-skid spikes help resist foot movement on rough trails. At 0.66 lb per pair, they are the lighter option compared with the MZYRH pedals, which are listed at 0.45 lb each.
Sealed bearings are intended to keep dirt and moisture away from the rotating parts, a useful feature for trail riding. The tradeoffs are the single red color option and a one-year limited warranty. The product data also gives the thread size as 9/16 inch in one field and an unclear value in another, so I would confirm fit before ordering. Choose these for a lightweight, roomy flat platform rather than clip-in versatility.
Pros:- Wide 101 mm platform provides generous shoe support
- Light 0.66 lb listed weight for the pair
- Stainless steel anti-skid spikes add grip on rough trails
- Sealed bearings and left/right markings support maintenance and installation
Cons:- Available only in red
- One-year limited warranty is shorter than the Shimano PD-EH500 warranty
- Thread-size information is inconsistent and should be verified
Best for: Trail riders who want a lightweight, wide aluminum platform with pinned grip and a conventional 9/16-inch crank fit.
Not ideal for: Riders who need neutral or multiple color choices, prefer a smaller platform, or cannot confirm the pedal thread size.
- Material:Aluminum alloy
- Platform width:101 mm
- Weight:0.66 lb (302 g)
- Color:Red
- Bearing type:Sealed
- Spindle:Chrome-molybdenum steel with carbon fiber bushing
- Thread size:Listed as 9/16 in and 16-Sep; verify before purchase
- Warranty:1 year limited
Our verdict“Pick the ROCKBROS if you want a light, broad flat pedal and are comfortable with its red finish and thread-fit check.”
GPMTER 9/16-Inch Aluminum Flat Bike Pedals with 16 Anti-Skid Pins
The GPMTER pedals offer a straightforward aluminum flat-pedal setup for riders who want grip without especially aggressive pins. Their 16 rounded anti-skid pins can help keep a shoe planted, while the rounded design is a less sharp-edged choice than the ROCKBROS Aluminum MTB Pedals’ stainless steel spikes. That may appeal to casual trail riders who value a less aggressive contact surface over maximum bite.
The sealed spindle is intended to limit water and dust entry, and the listed 9/16-inch threads fit many adult bikes. Compared with the wider ROCKBROS platform, however, the GPMTER’s 3.5 × 3.5-inch dimensions provide a more compact foothold. The rounded pins may also offer less hold when riding rough trails or in wet conditions. These are a sensible basic option for varied riding, but not my pick for riders seeking a large platform or the strongest pin engagement.
Pros:- Aluminum alloy construction
- Sixteen rounded pins provide moderate shoe grip
- Sealed spindle helps keep water and dust out
- 9/16-inch threads suit many adult BMX, mountain, and road bikes
Cons:- Rounded pins may grip less aggressively than sharper pin designs
- Compact listed dimensions offer less foot support than the ROCKBROS 101 mm platform
- Not compatible with bikes using 1/2-inch pedal threads
Best for: Adult riders with 9/16-inch crank threads who want compact aluminum flats and moderate pin grip for mixed road and trail use.
Not ideal for: Aggressive trail riders who need a large platform and sharp, high-bite pins, or owners of bikes with 1/2-inch pedal threads.
- Brand:GPMTER
- Material:Aluminum alloy
- Thread size:9/16 in
- Anti-skid pins:16, rounded
- Dimensions:3.5 × 3.5 in
- Weight:15.2 oz
- Compatible bike types:BMX, mountain, and road bikes
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“Choose the GPMTER for a compact, moderately grippy flat pedal on a bike with confirmed 9/16-inch crank threads.”
MZYRH Mountain Bike Pedals, 9/16-Inch CNC-Machined Aluminum Alloy, Sealed 3-Bearing
The MZYRH pedals are a good match for riders drawn to an aluminum flat pedal with a specified three sealed bearings. That bearing setup is the main distinction from the GPMTER’s sealed-spindle description, which does not specify a bearing count. The MZYRH’s 105 × 91 mm platform also offers a larger stated footprint than the GPMTER’s 3.5 × 3.5-inch dimensions, giving trail shoes more room to settle on the pedal.
At 0.45 lb each, the listed weight is substantial enough that weight-conscious buyers should compare the pair total with lighter options such as the ROCKBROS Aluminum MTB Pedals. The product data lists broad compatibility across mountain, road, BMX, exercise, fixie, and folding bikes, but the 9/16-inch thread still needs to match the crank. The description does not specify pin count or pin material, so riders who want detailed grip information may prefer a more fully documented option.
Pros:- Three sealed bearings are specified for smooth pedal rotation
- 105 × 91 mm platform provides a broad foothold
- Aluminum alloy construction
- Left and right markings help prevent installation mix-ups
Cons:- Listed weight of 0.45 lb each may not suit riders focused on minimizing pedal weight
- Pin count and pin material are not specified
- Requires 9/16-inch crank threads despite broad bike-type compatibility
Best for: Riders seeking a roomy aluminum flat pedal with a specified three-bearing design and confirmed 9/16-inch crank compatibility.
Not ideal for: Weight-focused riders, buyers who need detailed pin specifications, or anyone whose cranks use a different thread size.
- Material:High-strength aluminum alloy
- Bearing:3 sealed bearings
- Thread size:9/16 in
- Weight:0.45 lb each
- Dimensions:4.1 × 3.58 × 1.0 in (105 × 91 × 26 mm) each
- Compatibility:Mountain, road, BMX, exercise, fixie, and folding bikes
- Installation markings:Left and right marked
- Origin:Imported
Our verdict“Choose the MZYRH if a broad platform and specified three-bearing construction matter more to you than minimizing weight or pin uncertainty.”
How We Picked
I ranked these mountain bike pedals by how clearly each option serves a real riding need, not by treating every flat pedal as interchangeable. The main criteria were pedal system, usable platform area, grip features such as pin placement, stated bearing and body construction, and how easy the design is to match with common riding shoes. I also considered versatility and the practical costs of each design, including the learning curve of clipless pedals, the fit implications of a large platform, and the maintenance needs of moving parts.
The Crankbrothers Stamp Large leads as the most compelling general flat-pedal choice, while Shimano’s two SPD options rank highly for riders who specifically want clipless engagement or a mixed flat-and-clipless setup. The remaining flat pedals are ordered by the clarity of their intended role and the useful differences visible in their names and stated features; close variants are not treated as automatic upgrades over one another. Because the product details supplied do not establish durability testing, exact dimensions, or long-term service performance, I avoid making claims on those points and recommend checking fit and compatibility before buying.
| mountain bike pedal | Material |
|---|---|
| ROCKBROS Nylon Fiber Platform | — |
| GEWAGE 9/16-Inch Flat Bike Ped | — |
| ROCKBROS Lightweight Aluminum | Aluminum alloy, carbon fiber, and stainless steel |
| FIFTY-FIFTY Mountain Bike Peda | — |
| Hapleby 9/16-Inch Flat Bike Pe | — |
| Universal 9/16-Inch Non-Slip P | Polypropylene (PP) |
| Crankbrothers Stamp Flat MTB P | — |
| ROCKBROS Aluminum Mountain Bik | CNC-machined aluminum alloy |
| MZYRH Mountain Bike Pedals | High-strength aluminum alloy |
| Shimano PD-M520 SPD Clipless B | Aluminum |
| Shimano PD-EH500 Dual-Sided SP | Aluminum |
| ROCKBROS Aluminum MTB Pedals W | Aluminum alloy |
| GPMTER 9/16-Inch Aluminum Flat | Aluminum alloy |
| MZYRH Mountain Bike Pedals | High-strength aluminum alloy |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Mountain Bike Pedals
Before choosing from this list, settle the interface and fit questions that product names alone cannot answer. A pedal can have plenty of pins yet still feel wrong if its platform does not suit your shoe, or if its body sits too close to a crank or frame. These broader checks can narrow the shortlist faster than comparing small differences between similar flat-pedal models.
Choose Flat, Clipless, or Dual-Sided Before Comparing Models
Flat pedals let you place and reposition a regular shoe without clipping in, which many trail riders prefer for quick foot movement and easier dab recovery. SPD clipless pedals connect compatible shoes to the pedal, offering a consistent connection but requiring practice to clip out smoothly. A dual-sided design such as the Shimano PD-EH500 gives you both interfaces, though you must orient the pedal to the side you want when starting. A common mistake is buying clipless pedals before checking that your shoes accept the matching cleats. If you are undecided, think about whether you value a familiar flat shoe setup more than a fixed shoe-to-pedal connection.
Match Platform Size to Your Shoe and Riding
A wider or longer platform can give more of the shoe sole a place to rest, but bigger is not automatically better. Large pedals may add clearance concerns near rocks, while a platform that is too small for your shoe can leave the foot feeling less supported. Check the manufacturer’s dimensions and compare them with your shoe sole rather than relying only on words such as large or wide. Riders with smaller feet may prefer a more compact body, while riders with larger shoes may want more contact area. Also check pedal clearance around the crank and frame, especially if your bike has tight spacing.
Treat Pins and Shoe Sole as a Pair
Grip depends on the interaction between pedal pins and the rubber pattern of your shoe, not pin count alone. Tall or aggressive pins may hold a soft, flat shoe firmly but can feel harsh underfoot and may damage a sole faster. Removable pins are useful when you want to replace damaged hardware or adjust the feel, but verify that replacement pins are available for the exact pedal. A frequent buying error is choosing a pedal for its pin total without checking pin placement or how the shoe’s tread can sit against the body. If possible, compare the pedal’s pin layout with the flat, relatively open sole of a dedicated flat-pedal shoe.
Compare Body Material Without Assuming It Predicts Everything
Nylon-composite and aluminum pedals offer different construction choices, but neither material alone tells you how a pedal will feel or hold up. Composite models may suit riders who want a non-metal body, while aluminum options appeal to those seeking a metal platform. Shape, thickness, pin layout, and bearing design also affect clearance, grip, and service needs. Avoid assuming that a heavier-looking or more elaborate body guarantees longer life; product specifications and access to replacement parts matter more. For a bike that sees regular wet or gritty rides, look for clear information about bearing service and replacement hardware before choosing.
Check Bearings and Serviceability for Your Conditions
Sealed-bearing wording can indicate a design intended to keep contaminants away from moving parts, but it does not reveal how easy the pedal is to service or whether parts are available. Riders who wash bikes often or ride in rain and mud should pay attention to service instructions and replacement options. A pedal with a stated multi-bearing layout is not automatically better for every buyer if its service process is unclear. Check the manufacturer’s guidance for lubrication, bearing replacement, and axle maintenance instead of treating a bearing count as a performance score. If you rarely service components, a straightforward design with accessible support may be a better fit than a feature list that sounds more advanced.
Verify Thread Size, Shoe Fit, and Cleat Compatibility
Most options in this roundup are listed as 9/16-inch, but verify your crank’s pedal threading before ordering, especially on older bikes or unusual builds. Clipless choices also require compatible shoes and the correct cleat standard; the Shimano SPD pedals are not a substitute for checking shoe compatibility. Confirm left and right pedal orientation during installation because the threads differ by side. Consider whether you need cleats included and whether your shoes allow the cleat to sit at a comfortable position. These checks prevent a pedal that looks right on paper from becoming an awkward or incompatible upgrade.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I choose the Shimano PD-M520 or the Shimano PD-EH500?
Choose the PD-M520 if you want a dedicated SPD clipless pedal with the same connection style on both sides. Pick the PD-EH500 if a flat side matters for casual rides, errands, or days when you do not want to wear clipless shoes. The dual-sided layout adds flexibility, but the pedal may need positioning before you can use the side you want. In either case, confirm that your shoes accept Shimano SPD cleats and that you are comfortable practicing clip-in and clip-out technique.
Are flat pedals a better choice than clipless pedals for a beginner?
Flat pedals are often an easier starting point because they work with regular shoes and let you put a foot down without first unclipping. That does not make them automatically safer or more capable; shoe grip and confidence still matter. Clipless pedals can suit beginners who are ready to practice the release motion in a controlled setting and want a consistent shoe connection. A dual-sided pedal can bridge those preferences, though it does not remove the need to learn the clipless side. Choose based on the interface you will use confidently, not on assumptions about what experienced riders prefer.
How do I know whether a large flat pedal will fit my shoes and bike?
Look up the pedal’s actual length and width, then compare those measurements with your shoe sole and the space around your crank. A larger platform may support more of a bigger shoe, but it can also increase the chance of pedal strikes on rocks or trail features. Check that the pedal will not contact the frame or other parts through a full crank rotation. The word large is not a standardized measurement, so use dimensions rather than a product label. If exact dimensions are unavailable, ask the seller or manufacturer before ordering.
Do more pins automatically mean better grip on flat pedals?
No. Grip depends on pin height, placement, condition, and how the pins interact with your shoe’s rubber and tread. More pins can create more contact points, but a crowded layout may not suit every sole, and aggressive pins can wear shoes or feel uncomfortable. Removable pins give you a way to replace damaged hardware or tune the feel if the design supports it. Compare the pin layout and shoe compatibility instead of choosing by the stated count alone. Keeping pins clear of packed mud also helps maintain a predictable connection.
Can I install any 9/16-inch pedal on my mountain bike?
Only if your crank uses 9/16-inch pedal threads and the pedal’s side and threading match the crank. Check the bike or crank specifications rather than relying on the bike being a mountain bike, since exceptions exist. Clipless pedals add a separate compatibility check: your shoes must accept the cleat standard used by the pedal. Installation also requires putting the left pedal on the left side and the right pedal on the right side because their threads are different. If you are unsure about your crank or thread size, confirm it with a bike shop before buying.
Conclusion
For a general-purpose flat setup, I would start with the Crankbrothers Stamp Large as the best overall pick, provided its platform size suits your shoes and bike clearance. For best value, compare the simpler ROCKBROS and other composite or alloy flats by platform dimensions, pin layout, and service support rather than assuming near-identical labels mean identical fit. The Shimano PD-M520 is my best premium-style choice for riders committed to SPD clipless riding, while the Shimano PD-EH500 is the better match for someone who wants a flat side as a fallback. Beginners who want a straightforward interface should begin with a flat pedal and compatible flat-pedal shoes; riders seeking a specific need—such as a wide platform, removable pins, or dual-sided use—should shortlist the model that directly provides it. Check thread size, shoe fit, and clearance before deciding.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
