The Nike Zegama Trail 2 is my best overall pick for runners who want a cushioned shoe built for longer trail outings, while the Pegasus Trail 5 GORE-TEX suits wet-weather routes and the Juniper Trail 2 Next Nature offers a simpler entry point. The main choice is between more cushioning and protection or a lighter, less specialized shoe for mixed surfaces. Nike’s Pegasus Trail models also appear here in both waterproof and non-waterproof versions, so matching the shoe to local weather matters. My ranking weighs trail suitability, versatility, protection and how clearly each option serves a different runner. Read on for the full comparison and a guide to choosing among these six models.
Get sports gear delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Zegama Trail 2 leads for cushioning-focused trail use; its role is more specialized than the Pegasus Trail 5’s mixed-surface appeal.
- Pegasus Trail 5 GORE-TEX is the weather-focused choice, but waterproofing makes the most sense for damp conditions, not every run.
- The standard Pegasus Trail 5 is the more adaptable daily option when wet-weather protection is not a regular need.
- The two Juniper models prioritize accessible trail use over the Zegama’s long-run cushioning and the Pegasus models’ broader road-to-trail positioning.
- Women’s and men’s versions broaden the fit choices, but buyers should compare the exact version and size rather than assume every model shares the same fit.
| Nike Zegama Trail 2 Men’s Running Shoes |  | Best for Technical Terrain | Sole material: Rubber | Outer material: Synthetic | Inner material: Tissue | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Nike Men’s Pegasus Trail 5 GORE-TEX Waterproof Trail Running Shoes |  | Best for Wet Conditions | Upper: Mesh with GORE-TEX waterproof membrane | Midsole: ReactX foam with Air Zoom in the forefoot | Outsole: Nike Trail ATC all-terrain blend | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Nike Women’s Juniper Trail 2 Next Nature Trail Running Shoes |  | Best for Everyday Trail Outings | Product type: Women’s trail running shoes | Construction: Lightweight | Cushioning: Supportive cushioning | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Nike Men’s Juniper Trail 3 Trail Running Shoes |  | Best for Straightforward Trail Use | Product type: Men’s trail running shoes | Intended use: Trail running and outdoor activities | Construction: Durable | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Nike Pegasus Trail 5 Men’s Trail Running Shoes (DV3864-004) Size 10 |  | Best Road-to-Trail Crossover | Model: DV3864-004 | Size: 10 | Color: Light Silver/College Grey/Dark Team Red/Barely Volt | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Nike Women’s Pegasus Trail 5 GORE-TEX Shoes |  | Best for Wet-Weather Versatility | Upper material: Mesh | Waterproof layer: GORE-TEX | Outsole material: Rubber | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Nike trail running shoe | Midsole | Upper | Intended use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nike Zegama Trail 2 Men’s Runn | Nike ZoomX | Engineered mesh | — |
| Nike Men’s Pegasus Trail 5 GOR | ReactX foam with Air Zoom in the forefoot | Mesh with GORE-TEX waterproof membrane | Trail running |
| Nike Women’s Juniper Trail 2 N | — | — | Trail running and outdoor activities |
| Nike Men’s Juniper Trail 3 Tra | — | — | Trail running and outdoor activities |
| Nike Pegasus Trail 5 Men’s Tra | ReactX foam | Breathable mesh | — |
| Nike Women’s Pegasus Trail 5 G | — | — | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Nike Zegama Trail 2 Men’s Running Shoes
The Nike Zegama Trail 2 is the strongest match here for runners who regularly leave smooth paths behind. Its Vibram Megagrip outsole is aimed at confident footing on rugged ground, while the ZoomX midsole adds cushioning for longer outings. Ankle gaiter and toe overlays add protection that the road-to-trail-oriented Pegasus Trail 5 does not emphasize in its listed features. That specialized setup comes with a narrower use case: it is less suited to casual wear, and the product information does not give enough detail to judge fit or water protection. Choose it over the standard Pegasus Trail 5 when traction and cushioning on rough trails take priority; choose the Pegasus when a breathable road-and-dirt crossover shoe matters more.
Pros:- Vibram Megagrip outsole is specified for traction on technical terrain.
- ZoomX midsole offers cushioning for extended trail runs.
- Engineered mesh upper is paired with toe overlays and an ankle gaiter.
Cons:- Specialized trail features make it less practical as a casual everyday shoe.
- The product data does not specify waterproofing or detailed fit information.
Best for: Trail runners tackling rough, technical routes who want grippy traction, cushioned support, and added protection around the foot.
Not ideal for: Runners mainly covering pavement or easy paths, and anyone seeking a casual everyday shoe or confirmed waterproofing.
- Sole material:Rubber
- Outer material:Synthetic
- Inner material:Tissue
- Outsole:Vibram Zegama with Megagrip
- Midsole:Nike ZoomX
- Upper:Engineered mesh
- Additional features:Ankle gaiter and toe overlays
Our verdict“Choose the Zegama Trail 2 for rugged routes where grip and cushioning matter more than everyday versatility.”
Nike Men’s Pegasus Trail 5 GORE-TEX Waterproof Trail Running Shoes
The Pegasus Trail 5 GORE-TEX stands apart from the non-waterproof Pegasus Trail 5 by prioritizing wet-weather coverage. Its GORE-TEX membrane is designed to keep water out, and the higher ankle cuff is intended to limit debris entry. Underfoot, ReactX foam and a forefoot Air Zoom unit provide a comfort-focused ride, while the Trail ATC outsole is built for mixed terrain. That coverage is useful on damp, muddy outings, but the cuff may feel restrictive to runners who prefer an open ankle, and a waterproof upper is less compelling in warm, dry conditions. Compared with the Zegama Trail 2, this is the more weather-focused pick; the Zegama is the clearer choice when technical-terrain traction is the main priority.
Pros:- GORE-TEX membrane is designed to keep water out.
- High ankle cuff helps limit debris entry.
- ReactX foam and forefoot Air Zoom add cushioning and responsiveness.
- Trail ATC outsole is intended for all-terrain use.
Cons:- Higher ankle cuff may feel restrictive to some runners.
- Waterproof construction may be unnecessary for dry-weather routes.
- The product information does not provide specific fit or weight details.
Best for: Runners who often train on wet trails and want a waterproof upper with added coverage around the ankle.
Not ideal for: Runners in hot, dry climates or those who dislike higher cuffs and want a less covered feel.
- Upper:Mesh with GORE-TEX waterproof membrane
- Midsole:ReactX foam with Air Zoom in the forefoot
- Outsole:Nike Trail ATC all-terrain blend
- Closure:Lace-up
- Intended use:Trail running
- Ankle feature:High ankle cuff intended to help keep debris out
Our verdict“Pick this Pegasus Trail 5 when wet-weather protection matters more than a lower, less restrictive upper.”
Nike Women’s Juniper Trail 2 Next Nature Trail Running Shoes
The Juniper Trail 2 Next Nature is the simpler option for women seeking a lightweight, supportive shoe for general outdoor use rather than a highly specialized trail build. Its description highlights comfort and durability across varied terrain, but it does not provide outsole, foam, or upper specifics. That makes it harder to recommend for technical routes than the Zegama Trail 2, whose Megagrip outsole and ZoomX midsole are clearly identified. It also lacks the stated wet-weather protection of the GORE-TEX Pegasus Trail 5. The Juniper makes more sense for straightforward trails and active wear when a basic, lighter-feeling option is the goal. Fit deserves attention: the supplied information notes that it may run small.
Pros:- Lightweight construction is suited to general outdoor activity.
- Supportive cushioning is described for comfortable wear.
- Designed for durability across varied terrain.
Cons:- The supplied product data does not identify the outsole or midsole materials.
- May run small, so fit may require extra care.
- No waterproofing details are provided.
Best for: Women looking for a lightweight, supportive shoe for routine trail walks, easy runs, and outdoor activities on varied but nontechnical paths.
Not ideal for: Runners who need verified high-grip outsole details, waterproof protection, or a roomy fit without sizing guidance.
- Product type:Women’s trail running shoes
- Construction:Lightweight
- Cushioning:Supportive cushioning
- Intended use:Trail running and outdoor activities
- Terrain:Various terrains
- Fit note:May run small for some wearers
Our verdict“Choose the Juniper Trail 2 Next Nature for uncomplicated outdoor use, but opt for the Zegama or GORE-TEX Pegasus when terrain or weather demands are higher.”
Nike Men’s Juniper Trail 3 Trail Running Shoes
The Juniper Trail 3 is a basic choice for men who want a durable trail shoe for outdoor activity without the stated weather-focused construction of the GORE-TEX Pegasus Trail 5. The supplied description points to comfort and support on rugged terrain, but gives no named foam, outsole compound, or upper material. That limited detail makes this a less certain choice for runners planning technical routes than the Zegama Trail 2, which specifies Vibram Megagrip traction and ZoomX cushioning. The Juniper may suit buyers who value a straightforward trail-oriented design, but there is not enough product information here to compare grip, cushioning, or fit closely. Choose it for general outdoor use; look to the better-specified models when a particular terrain or weather feature is a must.
Pros:- Described as durable for outdoor terrain.
- Comfort and support are listed as intended strengths.
- Trail-focused design suits outdoor activity.
Cons:- Product data does not specify the outsole, midsole, or upper materials.
- No waterproofing information is provided.
- Limited technical details make it difficult to match the shoe to demanding routes.
Best for: Men seeking a durable, supportive shoe for regular outdoor activity on trails who do not need a specified waterproof membrane or premium outsole.
Not ideal for: Runners choosing gear for technical routes or wet-weather training who need clearly documented traction and weather protection.
- Product type:Men’s trail running shoes
- Intended use:Trail running and outdoor activities
- Construction:Durable
- Support:Supportive design
- Comfort:Designed for comfort during outdoor activities
- Terrain:Rugged terrain
Our verdict“Consider the Juniper Trail 3 for general trail use, but choose the Zegama Trail 2 or GORE-TEX Pegasus when specific performance features matter.”
Nike Pegasus Trail 5 Men’s Trail Running Shoes (DV3864-004) Size 10
The standard Pegasus Trail 5 is the most versatile pick here for runners splitting time between dirt paths and pavement. Its ReactX foam midsole supports a responsive, cushioned ride, while the breathable mesh upper favors ventilation over weather protection. Compared with the GORE-TEX Pegasus Trail 5, this version is explicitly not water resistant, so it is better suited to dry outings than persistent rain. It is also less specialized for rough terrain than the Zegama Trail 2, whose Vibram Megagrip outsole is named for technical trails. Flywire is listed for a secure fit, though tighter woven mesh in high-wear areas may reduce flexibility. The included size and color make this listing more specific than the other models, so check those details before choosing.
Pros:- ReactX foam midsole is designed for a responsive, cushioned ride.
- Breathable mesh upper suits dry-weather use.
- Outsole is described as durable for both dirt paths and roads.
- Flywire technology is listed for a secure fit.
Cons:- Not water resistant, limiting suitability for wet conditions.
- Tighter woven mesh in high-wear areas may reduce flexibility.
- Less specifically equipped for technical terrain than the Zegama Trail 2.
Best for: Men who want one shoe for dry trail runs that include road sections and value breathable construction over waterproof coverage.
Not ideal for: Runners who regularly train in wet conditions or prioritize maximum grip for technical, rugged trails.
- Model:DV3864-004
- Size:10
- Color:Light Silver/College Grey/Dark Team Red/Barely Volt
- Sole material:Rubber
- Midsole:ReactX foam
- Upper:Breathable mesh
- Water resistance:Not water resistant
- Technology:Flywire
Our verdict“Choose this Pegasus Trail 5 for dry mixed-surface running; choose its GORE-TEX counterpart for wet weather or the Zegama for more technical trails.”
Nike Women’s Pegasus Trail 5 GORE-TEX Shoes
I’d choose the Women’s Pegasus Trail 5 GORE-TEX when a route mixes pavement and dirt and rain protection matters as much as trail grip. Its GORE-TEX waterproof layer helps keep feet dry in wet conditions, while the rubber outsole is described as suitable for both road and dirt—more versatile for mixed routes than a dedicated trail pick such as the Nike Zegama Trail 2. The lightweight design also suits runners who want coverage without a bulky-feeling shoe.
The tradeoff is that waterproof protection can feel less appealing in warm, dry weather, and the available details don’t establish how its traction performs on technical terrain. Sizing may run small for some, so I’d be cautious about choosing a snug fit without checking sizing guidance. This is a weather-minded all-rounder, not the clearest choice for runners prioritizing maximum trail-specific capability.
Pros:- GORE-TEX layer helps keep feet dry in wet weather
- Rubber outsole is suited to both road and dirt surfaces
- Lightweight design can suit mixed-surface runs
- Women’s-specific model in the Pegasus Trail 5 GORE-TEX line
Cons:- May run small for some users, making fit selection less straightforward
- Waterproof coverage may be less comfortable in warm, dry conditions
- Product details do not specify traction performance on technical terrain
Best for: Women running varied road-to-dirt routes in rainy or changeable weather who want waterproof coverage in a lightweight shoe.
Not ideal for: Runners focused on hot, dry conditions or technical trails who would rather prioritize breathability or trail-specific performance over waterproofing.
- Upper material:Mesh
- Waterproof layer:GORE-TEX
- Outsole material:Rubber
- Closure:Lace-up
- Listed size:Women’s 8.5 / Men’s 7
- Intended surfaces:Road and dirt
- Origin:Imported
Our verdict“Choose this if you want a lightweight women’s trail shoe for rainy mixed-surface running, but look elsewhere if dry-weather breathability or technical-trail grip is your priority.”
How We Picked
I ranked these shoes by how well their intended strengths match common trail-running needs: cushioning for longer outings, grip and stability on uneven ground, weather protection, and versatility across trails and roads. I also considered how easy each model is to recommend for a distinct buyer, rather than treating every Nike trail shoe as interchangeable. The Zegama Trail 2 earns the top spot for its clear cushioned-trail role; the Pegasus Trail 5 options follow for their useful range, with the GORE-TEX versions judged separately from the standard shoe.
The Juniper models rank lower because their appeal is more focused on straightforward trail use, rather than the broader performance or weather-specific advantages of the leading picks. I treat the men’s and women’s listings as separate buying options, while avoiding assumptions about fit from the product name alone. Product details and model versions can vary, so I recommend confirming the exact style, intended conditions and fit information before choosing.
| Nike trail running shoe | Midsole | Upper | Intended use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nike Zegama Trail 2 Men’s Runn | Nike ZoomX | Engineered mesh | — |
| Nike Men’s Pegasus Trail 5 GOR | ReactX foam with Air Zoom in the forefoot | Mesh with GORE-TEX waterproof membrane | Trail running |
| Nike Women’s Juniper Trail 2 N | — | — | Trail running and outdoor activities |
| Nike Men’s Juniper Trail 3 Tra | — | — | Trail running and outdoor activities |
| Nike Pegasus Trail 5 Men’s Tra | ReactX foam | Breathable mesh | — |
| Nike Women’s Pegasus Trail 5 G | — | — | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Nike Trail Running Shoes
The right Nike trail shoe depends less on the word “trail” in the name and more on where you run, how long you stay out and what conditions you face. These broader checks can help avoid paying for protection you rarely use or choosing a shoe that feels under-equipped on your regular routes.
Match Cushioning to Your Typical Run
Think about the surface and duration you run most often, not your longest planned adventure. More cushioning can make extended outings feel more comfortable, but it may also feel like more shoe than you want on short, quick runs. A lower-key trail shoe can feel easier to manage when your routes are familiar and relatively mild. A common mistake is choosing maximum cushioning because it sounds safer without checking whether the added bulk suits your stride. If you alternate short runs and long days, prioritize the use you repeat most. The Zegama’s role in this lineup is a useful reference point for runners who value cushioning, while the Pegasus Trail family offers a more mixed-use alternative.
Decide Whether You Need Waterproofing
GORE-TEX can help keep rain and surface moisture out, which can be welcome on wet paths and in changeable weather. It does not make a shoe a universal choice for every climate or every wet trail condition. Waterproof footwear can feel less appealing in warm weather, and water entering over the collar may take longer to escape. Buyers sometimes choose a waterproof version for occasional drizzle, then wear it through many dry, hot miles. Compare your usual weather, puddle depth and seasonal use before paying for a protective upper. In this group, the standard Pegasus Trail 5 gives a clearer option for runners who do not need that added barrier.
Be Honest About Your Trail Surfaces
Trail shoes cover a wide range, from packed park paths to rocky, muddy or steep terrain. A shoe that works well for maintained paths may not offer the same confidence on loose or technical ground. Look at the terrain you encounter most, and check the model’s outsole and upper details against those conditions. Avoid assuming that every shoe labeled “trail” is equally capable on mud or rock. If your runs mix pavement with easy trails, versatility may matter more than a highly specialized trail setup. For rougher routes, prioritize secure footing and protection over road-friendly feel alone.
Treat Fit as a Model-Specific Decision
Fit can differ between shoe models and between men’s and women’s versions, so do not choose by category label alone. Allow space for toes to spread and for mild foot movement on descents, while keeping the heel secure. Trying shoes on later in the day can help account for feet that swell during activity. A frequent buying error is selecting a snug road-running fit without accounting for downhill movement or thicker trail socks. Check the current sizing guidance for the exact model and listing. If your feet are wide or you use orthotics, confirm compatibility before relying on a general size recommendation.
Choose Versatility or Specialization
A versatile shoe can be a sensible choice if you want one pair for road links and easy trails, while a more trail-focused model may suit runners who spend most of their time off pavement. Specialized features can improve comfort for a particular use, but they may add weight, warmth or a less natural feel on roads. Consider how often you will use the shoe’s defining feature before making it your only pair. The Pegasus Trail options illustrate this tradeoff: the standard version favors mixed use, while GORE-TEX targets wet conditions. The Juniper options make more sense when straightforward trail running matters more than broad road-to-trail flexibility.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which of these Nike trail shoes is the best choice for a first trail-running pair?
I would start by matching the shoe to easy, familiar trails rather than buying for the most technical terrain you might try someday. The Juniper Trail 2 Next Nature is the clearest entry-level option in this group, while the standard Pegasus Trail 5 is worth comparing if your runs include pavement as well as trails. Neither choice removes the need to check fit and the surface grip you need. If your routes are rocky, steep or frequently muddy, prioritize traction and protection over the simplest starting point. Choose the model that fits your regular runs, not just your first outing.
Should I choose the Pegasus Trail 5 GORE-TEX or the standard Pegasus Trail 5?
Choose the GORE-TEX version if rain, wet grass or shallow surface moisture are regular parts of your running conditions. The standard Pegasus Trail 5 is the more sensible match when you mainly run in dry weather or want a less weather-specific shoe for mixed road and trail routes. Waterproofing does not prevent water from entering over the top, and it can feel less comfortable in warm conditions. Think about the weather you run in most months, not just the worst day of the year. The two versions serve different priorities rather than one being a universal upgrade.
Is the Zegama Trail 2 a good pick if I mostly run short, easy trails?
It can work, but its place at the top of this roundup reflects its appeal to runners seeking a more cushioning-focused trail option, especially for longer outings. For short runs on maintained paths, you may not benefit as much from a shoe built around that priority. The Juniper models offer a more straightforward alternative in this lineup, and the standard Pegasus Trail 5 is a useful comparison if your routes include roads. Consider how the shoe feels at your usual pace and distance, not only its stated category. A more specialized choice makes the most sense when its main strength matches your routine.
Do I need a separate Nike trail shoe if I already run in road shoes?
Not necessarily if your off-road routes are smooth, dry park paths and your road shoes provide enough grip and stability for them. A trail-specific pair becomes more useful when you regularly encounter loose ground, uneven surfaces or wet conditions. If you run to a trail on pavement and then continue off-road, the Pegasus Trail 5’s mixed-use role may suit you better than a more specialized option. Avoid buying a trail shoe just for occasional easy paths if your current pair handles them comfortably. Let the surface and frequency of your trail runs guide the decision.
How should I choose between the men’s and women’s listings?
Start with the exact version that matches your feet, then check the brand’s current size chart and product fit notes. Men’s and women’s listings are not interchangeable labels for every runner, and the listed size alone does not tell you how a shoe will fit. If you are between sizes, have wider feet or plan to use thicker socks, a try-on or a retailer with a suitable return policy can reduce guesswork. Compare the intended model carefully, since this roundup includes both men’s and women’s versions of the Pegasus Trail 5 GORE-TEX. Comfort and secure heel hold matter more than choosing a listing based on its name.
Conclusion
Best overall: I recommend the Nike Zegama Trail 2 for runners who put cushioned trail comfort high on their list. Best value-style pick: the Juniper Trail 2 Next Nature is the straightforward option for buyers seeking an entry into trail running without choosing a weather-specific shoe. Best for beginners: start with the Juniper Trail 2 Next Nature for familiar, less demanding routes, or compare the standard Pegasus Trail 5 if you also run on roads. Best for wet-weather needs: choose either Pegasus Trail 5 GORE-TEX listing that matches your preferred fit. Best for mixed surfaces: the standard Pegasus Trail 5 is my pick when road links and dry trails share the same run. The Juniper Trail 3 is another focused option for buyers who want a dedicated trail model; select it over a Pegasus only if that more trail-centered role fits your routes.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
